Sylvan Dale Guest Ranch

 
 
 

Fishing Seasons and Conditions

Spring


According to Ranch guide Greg Sheets, writing in “Trout Tales” published by Bob’s Fly Shop in Loveland, the Big Thompson River in April “can be a very good month. Winter’s ice has finally melted away, run-off has yet to occur, and the first real hatch of the season begins. The blue-winged olive mayfly is surely welcome to both the fish and the fisherman as it is the first time we’ve seen those little "sailboats" since last October! A good choice for a pattern is the good old Adams in a #18. There are other more up-dated patterns around, but a regular or parachute Adams will catch the wild browns and rainbows of the River. Best places to look for a hatch depends on the weather conditions (watch out for those freak spring snow storms!) and the water temperature.” May can be a very good time or it can be a very bad time depending on the amount of run-off there is and the late spring weather. The first two weeks should produce some fine nymphing using large (#8) golden stonefly nymphs. The bugs are starting their annual migration towards the shore so that they can crawl out of their shucks and fly off to produce another generation. Not all of the 'stones will be of the golden variety as there are good numbers of brown and black ones moving. I just seem to have more luck with the golden patterns, but then again, that's the one that I use the most. Go figure! There will also be a pretty good BWO hatch this month, but fish it early. Once the water starts to come up in earnest it will be hard to find a trout willing to bust up through the raging water to take your #18 parachute Adams.”
The Spring runoff can occur any time between mid-May and late June. During this time the river is still fishable, but usually from the banks along the sides. By mid-July you can usually count on a normal flow. The spring-fed lakes are unaffected by runoff.

The Big Valley Lakes are boiling with activity in late March, April and May. This is the period for the big chironomid midge hatches In late April and May, the callibaetis mayflies emerge in small but constant numbers. Based on two years worth of fishing reports of 75 anglers, Mother Lake yielded 362 trout during the April-May period. The most successful flies included the giant midge emerger (also called bow-tie buzzer), the Parachute Adams size 16 or 18, and size 8 or 6 woolly buggers (usually olive) and leeches (purple). Muddlers and copper muddlers also took fish.

Summer


The Big Valley Lakes are all full of water and the trout are actively feeding. June is the period for continuing midge hatches, increasing callibaetis mayfly activity and the beginning of damselfly activity Based on two years worth of fishing reports of 85 anglers, Mother Lake yielded 546 trout during the June-July period. The most successful flies included damsel drys, damsel nymphs, woolly buggers and rabbit leeches in olive, black and purple colors, the Parachute Adams size 16 or 18. Crayfish imitations also took fish. July-August is the period for prime damselfly activity. Based on two years worth of fishing reports of 107 anglers, during the July-August period, Mother Lake yielded 563 trout. The most popular dry fly during this period, by a wide margin, was the damsel adult, followed, in order, by hoppers (tied madam X style), beetles, ants, and callibaetis duns and spinners (a Parachute Adams with white tails, size 16, is a good imitation). Under the surface, the most successful fly was the damsel nymph (imitated by a small olive woolly bugger, size 12 or 10), along with the usual assortment of olive, black and purple woolly buggers and zonkers. Small nymphs and midges size 20 also caught fish.

The Big Thompson River. By mig-July the runoff usually subsides and the River flowing through the Ranch grounds becomes transformed into its beautiful, clear, sparkling, wadeable self. Caddis hatches are phenomenal, with clouds of the little tent-moths swarming around tree limbs along the River. The trout resume their usual feeding positions and start charging after dries. During the 5 PM to dusk feeding frenzy period, they take almost anything you throw at them. The average size river fish is 13 inches, but sixteen inchers are fairly common common. Occassionaly a 25-inch brown is landed. On July 22 I was wading upstream with my two-fly rig dangling in the water behind me when a 14-inch brown grabbed the bottom fly, a size 14 sparkle caddis emerger. I decided to fish the riffle back downstream, holding the rod tip high, dragging the dropper through the water and bouncing my upper fly, a big size 10 Royal Trude, along the surface. The trout went crazy launching themselves at this moving target, like a bunch of addicts who know it's wrong but just can't help themselves. Most of them missed, but by the end of the hour I landed six nice trout between 13 and 16 inches, half browns and half rainbows. What fun!

Fall


The Big Thompson River runs low and clear (and very wadeable) in the fall. This means spectacular dry fly fishing. I often rig a dry fly (a size 16 elk-hair caddis, a 14 royal trude, or a 16 parachute adams pattern) as a strike indicator, with a light-weight nymph or wet fly (an old-fashioned size 14 blue quill wet is great) as a dropper.

The Big Valley Lakes are ready for hoppers and beetles. Ants, drowned or floating, now come into their own. Based on two years worth of fishing reports of 87 anglers, Mother Lake yielded 348 trout during the August-September period. The most successful dry flies, in order, included X-legged hoppers (which also caught the biggest trout), damsel drys, ants, beetles, callibaetis spinners, and parachute adams. The most successful sub-surface flies included woolly buggers, especially olive-colored) damsel nymphs, leeches, especially olive, and size 20 midges fished as droppers. Pheasant tail nymphs, crayfish and shrimp imitations also took fish.

Winter


Although many Colorado anglers hand up their gear when winter hits, our mild foothills climate and constant temperature spring water keeps our trophy lakes fishable most of the year.
The Big Valley Lakes continue to be fishable through part of the winter months of December, January and February. The springs keep parts of the lakes unfrozen on many days. On December 13 several years ago, Brad Bischoff of Ft. Collins landed 15 rainbows between 18 and 22 inches, and one 26-inch monster rainbow, on an olive leech with a full sinking line in Mother Lake. Winter anglers most frequently mentioned the following most effective flies in order of importance: Woolly buggers and rabbit leeches, especially olive colored, also black and purple mentioned; small midge emergers (size 18-24); small nymphs, including prince, pheasant tail, hare’s ear and bead head hare’s ear.
According to fishing permit forms turned in, the lakes were visited a total of 46 times in March a two-year period, and some 113 trout were landed. The most effective flies during this month were olive or black woolly buggers, black and purple leeches, and various small nymphs, especially pheasant tails, hare’s ear and prince nymphs. Midges, both adults and emergers, were also mentioned frequently.

The Big Thompson River. The Big Thompson River fishes well through the first big snow and freeze, then the water dwindles in flow and the trout head for the deep holes. According to Ranch guide Greg Sheets, writing in Trout Tales newsletter produced by Bob’s Fly Shop, “October can be a very special time on the Big Thompson. Fall is in full swing and the colors of the turning leaves are an added bonus to the usually excellent fishing. We have a second Baetis hatch that reaches it's climax in the middle of the month that gets the fish "looking up" for the last time of the season. A parachute Adams, Comparadun or a CDC dun is almost a sure bet for some excellent dry fly fishing. The water level will be low, so use 6x or even 7x tippets. The fish have "seen it all" by now, which means that a careful approach and good presentation is a must. Fishing like this will be good practice for the winter midging just around the corner.” In March, the river starts to open up and the midges begin showing up in numbers significant enough to kick the trout into a surface feeding display. Perhaps my favorite adult (dry fly) pattern is the Griffith’s Gnat. It's a very easy pattern to tie and is so effective when you encounter rising fish this month that it is one of those "confidence flies" that makes you smile when you tie it on. You just KNOW you'll catch fish!

 

Colorado Dude & Guest Ranch Association Dude Ranchers' Association